Every meeting

23 Jul 2026 Major League Soccer	Columbus Crew	1–2	New York City FC	L
10 May 2026 Major League Soccer	New York City FC	3–0	Columbus Crew	L

This record covers meetings from 10 May 2026 onwards. Earlier games between these teams aren't on the site yet, so the all-time totals may be higher.
W / D / L from Columbus Crew's side. Penalty shootouts count as draws.