| 29 May 2025
PSL Premiership |
 Supersport United |
1–1 |
 Golden Arrows |
D |
| 30 Oct 2024
PSL Premiership |
Golden Arrows |
0–0 |
Supersport United |
D |
| 3 Apr 2024
PSL Premiership |
Golden Arrows |
2–2 |
Supersport United |
D |
| 29 Aug 2023
PSL Premiership |
Supersport United |
0–3 |
Golden Arrows |
W |
| 5 Mar 2023
PSL Premiership |
Supersport United |
2–1 |
Golden Arrows |
L |
| 7 Jan 2023
PSL Premiership |
Golden Arrows |
2–1 |
Supersport United |
W |
| 2 Apr 2022
PSL Premiership |
Golden Arrows |
3–2 |
Supersport United |
W |
| 25 Aug 2021
PSL Premiership |
Supersport United |
3–1 |
Golden Arrows |
L |
| 14 Aug 2021
MTN8 · Quarter-finals |
Golden Arrows |
2–2 (aet, 4–3 pens) |
Supersport United |
D |
| 21 Apr 2021
PSL Premiership |
Supersport United |
0–1 |
Golden Arrows |
W |
| 28 Oct 2020
PSL Premiership |
Golden Arrows |
3–1 |
Supersport United |
W |
| 1 Feb 2020
PSL Premiership |
Golden Arrows |
1–0 |
Supersport United |
W |
| 5 Nov 2019
PSL Premiership |
Supersport United |
0–0 |
Golden Arrows |
D |
| 2 Nov 2019
Carling Knockout · Quarter-finals |
Supersport United |
0–1 |
Golden Arrows |
W |
| 10 Feb 2019
PSL Premiership |
Golden Arrows |
2–3 |
Supersport United |
L |
| 28 Oct 2018
PSL Premiership |
Supersport United |
1–1 |
Golden Arrows |
D |
| 14 Jan 2018
PSL Premiership |
Golden Arrows |
1–0 |
Supersport United |
W |
| 31 Oct 2017
PSL Premiership |
Supersport United |
3–0 |
Golden Arrows |
L |
| 8 Feb 2017
PSL Premiership |
Supersport United |
5–2 |
Golden Arrows |
L |
| 28 Sep 2016
PSL Premiership |
Golden Arrows |
1–1 |
Supersport United |
D |